Why would I not want BizTalk

Home Page › Forums › BizTalk 2004 – BizTalk 2010 › Why would I not want BizTalk

Viewing 1 reply thread
  • Author
    Posts
    • #18379

      We are about to invest in a new ERP system. We’re down to two choices Dynamics Nav and Dynamics AX. The AX provider has proposed BizTalk in the solution for both exchanging flat files PO’s with our customers and x.12 with our vendors. The NAV folks are saying BizTalk is over kill for us and is pushing Adeptia for the flat files and something else for x.12. I’ve installed the trial version of BizTalk and done some simple translating. While I’d say there’s nothing easy about BizTalk. I don’t see that’s it over kill.

       I’d really appreciate some feed back you guys that using it everydayWe currently exchange about 500 to 1000 flat files PO’s a day with about 20 customers using a mapper / transulator I wrote while not bad it needs to go….We are not exchanging any x.12 at this time.

      Thanks!

    • #18381

      We
      are using BizTalk for essentially the same purpose. We use it to
      translate Flat File and X12 EDI invoices into a SQL database. We only
      have 15 suppliers right now and are processing 15-20 files a day
      (~1000-2000 invoices). It is definitely overkill for this particular
      application, but we plan on using BizTalk to replace older DTS packages
      on our various databases and future projects.

      I found the learning curve a bit steep, but once I got over the hurdles it is very easy to work with.

      BizTalk
      is a great solution because of its integration with other Microsoft
      technologies. We use Visual Studio for other development project so all
      of our developers are familiar with the tool set. We plan on using
      SharePoint services to provide system information to management and the
      JDE adapaters to communicate with our ERP.

      IMO if your company
      uses nothing but Microsoft OS’s for desktops/servers and your
      development tools are all Microsoft, why buy a tool from another
      company when Microsoft makes a similar tool…probably a better tool 🙂

       

Viewing 1 reply thread
  • The forum ‘BizTalk 2004 – BizTalk 2010’ is closed to new topics and replies.